Tucked away beneath the historic floorboards of The Blue Posts in Soho lies a culinary gem that redefines the London dining scene. Evelyn’s Table, a former beer cellar transformed into a Michelin-starred sanctuary, offers just 12 seats along a sleek marble counter. This week, I was lucky enough to descend the narrow stairs to experience their latest menu, and the result was nothing short of spectacular.
The Performance: Counter Dining at Its Peak
At Evelyn’s Table, there is no “back of house.” The kitchen is the stage, and the chefs are the performers. Led by Head Chef Seamus Sam, whose tenure at acclaimed spots like Restaurant Story and The Clove Club shines through in his precision, the team moves with a grace that turns a meal into a piece of interactive theater.
As a diner, you aren’t just eating; you are watching the delicate placement of a morel, the precise slicing of a lamb saddle, and the intense focus of a team operating at the highest level. It is communal, intimate, and inherently social. On top of that, the team are more than happy to engage and chat.
The Menu: A Journey Through April 2026
The menu I tasted on Tuesday 28th April 2026 was a masterclass in balancing British seasonality with global techniques:
Cornish Red Mullet: The meal opened with a vibrant dish featuring watermelon radish and a sharp, aromatic Rhubarb & Blood Orange Nahm Jim. The citrus notes perfectly cut through the richness of the mullet.
Barbecued Trout: This course introduced a wonderful smoky depth, paired with a fennel salad and a complex North Indian spice blend. My dining companion noted it felt like a beautiful coming together of North and South Indian tastes; when we asked Chef Seamus about the direction, he simply said his inspiration was that this is exactly the type of food he loves to eat. The addition of crab and a winter tomato sauce created a rich, comforting layer of umami.
St. Bride’s Chicken: A highlight of the evening, the chicken was executed to perfection, boasting an incredibly crispy skin while remaining succulent and moist throughout. It was served with tender white asparagus and earthy morels. The unexpected twist of lemongrass and satay sauce added a bright, nutty finish that felt incredibly modern.
Saddle of Herdwick Lamb: The “main” event featured perfectly rendered lamb alongside crushed Jersey Royals, smoked aubergine, and peas. The addition of wild garlic and seaweed provided a coastal, seasonal punch that tied the dish together. It was so good that one of our fellow diners who had chosen a pescatarian menu was convinced to swap out her fish dish for some lamb….and she did not regret her decision!
Japanese Yuzu Cheesecake: For dessert, a sophisticated blend featuring fresh, seasonal strawberry, shiso, and black sesame. The Sake Kasu ice cream was a revelation, creamy, slightly fermented, and the perfect cool finish to the evening.
The Liquid Gold: Wine & Service
While Evelyn’s Table is famous for its curated wine pairings, offering paths like the “Firm Favourites” or the more adventurous “Path Less Trodden”, we decided to explore the list à la carte this visit.
The wine list is a treasure trove of low-intervention bottles and classic vintages alike. We must give a special mention to the fabulous sommelier, whose passion was infectious. They didn’t just pour wine; they told the story of the soil and the producer, guiding us toward bottles that harmonized beautifully with the bold flavors of Chef Seamus’s cooking. Their expertise ensures that even if you bypass the set pairing, your glass will never be anything less than perfect.
Final Verdict
Evelyn’s Table remains one of the most rewarding bookings in London. It’s a place where the barrier between chef and guest disappears, leaving only great food, exceptional wine, and the low hum of Soho life far above your head.
Plan your visit: Reservations are released in blocks and disappear fast. I recommend arriving early for a glass of wine at The Mulwray, the elegant wine bar located just one floor above the cellar.
For more inspring travel and dining insights, follow us at @blueskiesescapes.
blueskiesescapes 